Challenge Five: The Fault In Our Stars

[Shailene [Host]]

Critiques

Romance Film

[Shailene [Host]]

Selena:

Shai: You are so head over heels but I cannot see your face at all. I wish even a an eye was visible. Quality is lacking a wee bit as well. Let's see how you do ranked among the rest.

Jared: Selena this is cute, but Shai is right, the man in your photo is overshadowing you physically because his large head is putting your face in shadow. However, you overshadow him metaphorically and I love the intensity and obvious love between the two of you. Well done!

Jensen:  Yikes, I spent more time trying to figure out who that guy was than on the picture itself.  The white speck in his hair is also distracting.  I love how romantic this is and how crazy in love you both look in this though.

[Shailene [Host]]

Matthew:

Shai: The quality is off with this but thats the only thing wrong here. This is believable and a photo-shoot even! I love the quirky, playful I only have eyes for you mood this gives. Nicely done.

Jared: I don't love this as much as Shai does. To be honest, the quality isn't great. Your girls looks very flirty, but look kind of cocky, like you're expecting her to love you and if she doesn't you'll move on with the flower in your mouth to the next girl. I dunno, I'm just not seeing little birds and hearts when I see this photo. Good luck!

Jensen:  OMG Natalia looks like shit here.  I've never seen her look awful in a picture before.  But submitting a photo with her was a huge risk and it paid off in your favour.  She looks head over heels in love with you.  I love the connection here.  I don't like the quality either but the bad quality seems to be all over Natalia, which works for you.  This is a really cute picture.

[Shailene [Host]]

Jennifer:

Shai: The quality is killing me this round. I also know that Jennifer has TONS to work with and has been other romantic leads, and this is the worst of them. I love me some X-Men but this is weak to me.

Jared: This is very obviously a movie still and the quality shows. However, I love the story behind this photo. The hot, peppy, popular girl going in for a kiss from the gross, nerdy, geek. It has a certain poetic value, but because of the quality, it suffers greatly. I still think it's believable though.

Jensen:  Using a screen cap is only good if you can get top notch quality, this is not.  It's really horrible quality and I'm not usually the stickler of quality in photos.   I'm sorry, but I just dont' like this, and I"m highly disappointed because I know you could rock this game with Jennifer if you just found all the right photos.

[Shailene [Host]]

James:

Shai: You have good quality, so HOORRAH for you this round. I like this it shows intensity and love, I like the little grin you have on your face. What I also like is that you gave us a kissing picture that you is the right before moment, where I can see your face.

Jared: Another movie still, but this one is such great quality that it passes for a photo shoot. I am lost in how in love you both look. James though, your hair is gross. It's all matted and unattractive and is the only thing I really don't like about the photo. Good job!

Jensen:  Now this is a screen cap with great quality.  The girl looks AWFUL, like worse than Natalia in her shoot, but you, you look good, so that's a plus.  I love the connection between the two of you even though she's ugly lol   Great job.

[Shailene [Host]]

Eva:

Shai: Eva, you look like you are so in love with that fine man and he could give two shits about you. So this leaves me feeling sorry for this lack of chemistry.

Jared: This is why I love that movie still are allowed in this series. I love this photo. I love how hard you are working to get your mans attention and how he is leaning his chin on your shoulder looking like he's in dreamland because he's holding you tight. It's brilliant and believeable. Well done!

Jensen:  Another screen cap done nicely.  Good job!   I love this photo.  The connection is so loving and strong.  He outshines you just a tad because his face is quite handsome, but you are absolutely beautiful and you both look in love.

[Shailene [Host]]

Ayumi:

Ayumi Hamasaki costars with Kurumi Hamazaki in this summer's most controversial and critically acclaimed film "The Fault In Our Stars".

The controversial film explores the life of a set of twins, inseparable since birth, and their budding romantic relationship and the social turmoil, moral taboo and public backlash from family, friends and peers unleashed in the wake of it.

Shai: I am a bit speechless and well to be honest.. Creeped out. So I had to actually first of all research if this was a real twin, it is not. Now I am not mad that its lady love, I love ladies loving ladies. I was hoping for some examples of love repressing the LGBT community.. I was not however expecting incestuous romance. I just don't know..I mean yes, I see the love.

Jared: Let's be real here, love is love, even if it's incest. I think this could have been just as believable as a lesbian love photo, but the added description makes me feel like it could be a story right out of Game of Thrones. You know how that series goes. Honestly, though, I'm seeing the love and I'm loving it. That's what this photoshoot was about and I really enjoy the story the photo itself is telling. Wonderful!

Jensen:  One thing I will say first off is this, thank you for not using that other photo lol  This one is much better looking.  I've never been a fan of the incest theme of this photo shoot, BUT as Jared said, it's about love, whether it's incest or not.  You two are in love with each other and it shows.  It's obvious and it's a job well done!!!

[Jensen [Judge]]

Elims up a little later <3

[Shailene [Host]]

I have out of town company visiting, so things will go up late tonight.

Thanks for Understanding.